Raising One Piece Flag Cannot Be Prosecuted Under Current Laws: Legal Experts

2 weeks ago 18

August 9, 2025 | 08:57 am

TEMPO.CO, Jakarta - The raising of the One Piece flag from the Japanese anime series took place ahead of the 80th anniversary of Indonesian Independence Day on August 17, 2025. Many citizens in different regions shared images on social media showing the skull-and-crossbones flag displayed on their homes and vehicles.

Known as the Jolly Roger, the flag was hoisted by some members of the public as a sign of dissatisfaction with the government’s performance and as an act of protest against social and political conditions they see as stagnant.

Coordinating Minister for Political, Legal, and Security Affairs Budi Gunawan said certain groups had provoked the public into lowering the dignity of the Red and White flag as a national symbol by replacing it with fictional emblems.

The former head of the National Intelligence Agency (BIN) stressed that defiling the honor of the Red and White flag carries criminal penalties under Law No. 24 of 2009 on the National Flag, Language, State Emblem, and National Anthem.

“The government will take firm and measured legal action if there are deliberate acts of provocation that undermine the dignity of national symbols,” Budi said in a written statement on Friday, August 1, 2025.

Legal Experts: Raising One Piece Flag Does Not Break the Law

Muhammad Fatahillah Akbar, a criminal law lecturer at Gadjah Mada University (UGM), said hoisting the Jolly Roger is a form of freedom of expression, comparable to raising party flags, football club flags, or music group banners.

While Law No. 24 of 2009 prohibits damaging the Red and White flag, it does not ban the use of other flags. “Hoisting the One Piece flag cannot be prosecuted,” Muhammad said in a text message on Sunday, August 3, 2025, adding that criminalizing such acts would violate constitutional protections for free expression.

Orin Gusta Andini, a criminal law lecturer at Mulawarman University, expressed a similar view, calling prosecution for raising the One Piece flag excessive.

“If it is hoisted without malicious intent to insult or degrade, I don’t think it can be subject to criminal prosecution,” Orin said on Sunday, August 3.

She explained that the act reflects freedom of expression and should not lead to charges, unless the flag is used to replace the national flag during ceremonies, which is prohibited.

Chairul Huda, a criminal law expert from Muhammadiyah University of Jakarta, also said hoisting the One Piece flag is part of citizens’ freedom of expression.

“It is a form of public sentiment, whether online or in public spaces,” Chairul said on Monday, August 4, 2025. He added that there is no issue as long as the flag is not placed higher than the Red and White flag.

What the Law Says About the National Flag

The use of the national flag is regulated under Law No. 24 of 2009, which provides detailed guidelines on proper handling, hoisting, and restrictions.

Article 7(1) states that the Red and White flag must be flown between sunrise and sunset, although it may be displayed at night under certain conditions. Article 7(3) mandates that all citizens hoist the national flag on August 17 in residential areas, educational institutions, offices, and public and private transportation. Local governments are required to provide flags for citizens who cannot afford them.

Article 21 of the same law outlines positioning rules:

  • The national flag must be placed to the right when displayed alongside other flags.

  • If flown with an organization’s pennant, it must be positioned higher.

  • It cannot be displayed alongside another organization’s pennant.

  • In processions, it must be carried at the front.

Articles 24 and related provisions in the latest Criminal Code list prohibited acts, including:

  • Disrespecting or damaging the flag, punishable by up to three years in prison or a Rp300 million fine.

  • Using it for commercial advertising, which carries a fine of up to Rp10 million.

  • Printing or sewing it on clothing, accessories, or equipment, also punishable by a Rp10 million fine.

  • Adding symbols or text to the flag, or using one that is torn, faded, or damaged.

  • Using it as a cover, wrapping, ceiling decoration, or allowing it to touch the ground or water.

Dian Rahma Fika, Intan Setiawanty, Novali Panji Nugroho, Amelia Rahima Sari, Dinda Shabrina, and Septo Yunus contributed to the writing of this article.

Editor’s Choice: Indonesian Truck Drivers Raise One Piece Flag as Symbol of Economic Hardship

Click here to get the latest news updates from Tempo on Google News



Those Who Refuse to Lower the One Piece Flag

2 menit lalu

Those Who Refuse to Lower the One Piece Flag

Here are some recent incidents involving the sweeping and raising of the One Piece flag in various regions.


TNI Searches for OPM Militants Who Burned Indonesian Flags in Papua

15 jam lalu

TNI Searches for OPM Militants Who Burned Indonesian Flags in Papua

The TNI reacted to TPNPB's instruction to its 36 regional divisions (Kodap) throughout Papua to forbid the raising of the Indonesian flag.


Papua's TPNPB-OPM Burns Indonesian Flags Seized from Security Forces

20 jam lalu

Papua's TPNPB-OPM Burns Indonesian Flags Seized from Security Forces

The TPNPB-OPM militia burns a number of Indonesian flags in the Pegunungan Bintang Regency, Papua, on Thursday, August 7, 2025.


Indonesian Truck Drivers Raise One Piece Flag as Symbol of Economic Hardship

1 hari lalu

Indonesian Truck Drivers Raise One Piece Flag as Symbol of Economic Hardship

Rahmat intentionally chose to install the One Piece flag as an expression of peaceful protest against increasingly difficult economic conditions.


Komnas HAM Concerned Over Indonesian Govt's Response to One Piece Flag Incident

2 hari lalu

Komnas HAM Concerned Over Indonesian Govt's Response to One Piece Flag Incident

National Commission on Human Rights (Komnas HAM) urges the Indonesian gov't to avoid excessive response to public expression in the future.


One Piece Flag in Indonesia: Here Are the Gov't Officials That Oppose It

2 hari lalu

One Piece Flag in Indonesia: Here Are the Gov't Officials That Oppose It

The phenomenon of hoisting the One Piece flag ahead of the Indonesian Independence Day has drawn public attention. Sufmi Dasco, Natalius Pigai, and Fadli Zon opposed it.


Today's Top 3 News: One Piece Flag Debate in Indonesia: The Problem with Raising the Flag on Independence Day

2 hari lalu

Today's Top 3 News: One Piece Flag Debate in Indonesia: The Problem with Raising the Flag on Independence Day

Here is the list of the top 3 news on Tempo English today.


Activist: One Piece Flags to Be Raised in Neglected Areas as Form of Protest

2 hari lalu

Activist: One Piece Flags to Be Raised in Neglected Areas as Form of Protest

Activist said the One Piece flags were meant as criticism of the government, hoping it would push authorities to recognize the issues and take action.


Prabowo Says He Has No Issue with One Piece Flag, Assures No Raids

2 hari lalu

Prabowo Says He Has No Issue with One Piece Flag, Assures No Raids

President Prabowo Subianto doesn't mind the hoisting of the One Piece flag by several communities as part of their creative expression.


One Piece Flag Debate in Indonesia: The Problem with Raising the Flag on Independence Day

2 hari lalu

One Piece Flag Debate in Indonesia: The Problem with Raising the Flag on Independence Day

The massive display of the skull-and-crossbones flag from the anime series One Piece has triggered a serious debate in public spaces and social media.


Read Entire Article
Parenting |