November 17, 2025 | 03:53 pm
TEMPO.CO, Jakarta - The judicial panel at the South Jakarta District Court granted the procedural objection, or exception, filed by Tempo in its civil case against Minister of Agriculture Amran Sulaiman, via an interim ruling on Monday, November 17, 2025.
The ruling stated, "The panel grants the Defendant's exception. The panel declares that the South Jakarta District Court does not possess the authority to adjudicate this case."
The judge additionally mandated the Ministry of Agriculture, acting as the plaintiff, to cover court expenses amounting to Rp240,000.
Tempo's Winning Legal Arguments
In its exception, Tempo's legal counsel asserted that the South Jakarta District Court lacks the jurisdictional authority to preside over the matter because the underlying issue constitutes a press dispute governed by Law Number 40 of 1999 concerning the Press. Consequently, according to Tempo's legal team, the Press Council holds the appropriate mandate to resolve this type of conflict.
Tempo's legal team further highlighted that the plaintiff had not exercised their legally provided right of reply, utilized the right of correction, or filed a formal complaint with the Press Council, as explicitly required by the Press Law. In a separate objection, Tempo's counsel characterized Amran's lawsuit as an Unjustified Lawsuit Against the Press (ULAP), suggesting it arose from an apparent instance of bad faith.
Tempo's legal team also contended that the plaintiff lacked the requisite legal standing to file the civil claim. They grounded this argument on two specific points. First, the complaint previously lodged with the Press Council was submitted by Wahyu Indarto, not by the Minister of Agriculture himself. Second, the subject of the dispute—the published news—did not focus its reporting on the Plaintiff, but rather on the operations of Bulog (the State Logistics Agency) concerning the procurement of rice and/or unhusked rice.
Tempo's legal counsel also maintained that the lawsuit constituted an abuse of rights and was lodged with ill intent. They suggested that the demand for Rp200 billion in damages indicated potential intimidation.
Tempo's legal representatives confirmed that Amran's lawsuit was misplaced because the contested news report was disseminated by tempo.co, a subsidiary of PT Info Media Digital, and not by PT Tempo Inti Media Tbk. Tempo's team also argued that Amran, in his capacity as a minister, was not legally entitled to sue on behalf of ministry employees, Bulog, and Indonesian farmers without clear, explicit legal authorization.
Minister Amran Sulaiman's Lawsuit
Amran filed the lawsuit against Tempo seeking Rp200 billion. He accused Tempo of engaging in unlawful conduct by failing to adhere to the Press Council's formal Statement of Assessment and Recommendation (PPR) concerning their cover story titled "Poles-poles Beras Busuk."
The controversial article, which featured a cover image of a rice sack and the headline "Poles-poles Beras Busuk," was promoted on social media platforms like Instagram and X (formerly Twitter). The story detailed Bulog's efforts to purchase all farmers' unhusked rice at a single price of Rp6,500 per kilogram.
Amelia Rahima Sari and Ervana Trikarinaputri contributed to the report
Editor's Choice: A House Commission's Criticism of the Agriculture Minister
Click here to get the latest news updates from Tempo on Google News
A House Commission's Criticism of the Agriculture Minister
1 jam lalu
The DPR and the Ombudsman question the policies of Agriculture Minister Amran Sulaiman after discovering suboptimal rice management.
Tempo Takes Home 2025 Editors Forum Journalism Award for Coverage of Drug Ad Manipulation
5 jam lalu
A reporting by Tempo has won the online media category at the 2025 Indonesian Editors Forum Journalism Awards.
Amran Sulaiman's Agricultural Populism
5 jam lalu
Food self-sufficiency is being achieved through populist policies. Like foam on the ocean.
Central Sulawesi Journalists Urge Court to Dismiss Amran's Case Against Tempo
6 jam lalu
Journalists in Central Sulawesi believe that the Tempo case will set a precedent for other media outlets.
Amran Sulaiman: Does Rice Production Increase or Not?
6 jam lalu
Amran Sulaiman claims that the Agriculture Ministry is capable of achieving its production target and avoiding rice import.
International Rights Group Urges Prabowo to Halt Minister's Lawsuit Against Tempo
4 hari lalu
International Freedom of Expression (IFEX) argues that the lawsuit by Prabowo's Minister Amran against Tempo undermines democracy in Indonesia.
Indonesia Eyeing to Build 100 Bulog Warehouses by Next Year
5 hari lalu
The President's request leads to the prioritization of building Bulog warehouses in areas lacking them and located in 3T regions.
Legal Experts: Soeharto's National Hero Title Could Be Challenged in Court
6 hari lalu
Legal experts suggest that the conferment of the national hero title to Soeharto could be legally challenged in the State Administrative Court.
Indonesian Student Press Association Condemns Minister Amran Sulaiman's Lawsuit Against Tempo
8 hari lalu
Indonesian Student Press Association (PPMI) condemns the lawsuit filed by Minister of Agriculture Amran Sulaiman against Tempo.
LBH Pers Flags Minister Amran Sulaiman's Goal to Silence Press in Tempo Lawsuit
9 hari lalu
The lawyer of Minister of Agriculture Amran Sulaiman stated that he will put the Rp200 billion from suing Tempo into the state treasury.
:strip_icc():format(jpeg)/kly-media-production/medias/5266416/original/075903700_1751001939-young-mother-playing-with-lovely-son-bedroom.jpg)
